What Should I Do When the Markets Crash?
Market downturns are uncomfortable. Even experienced investors feel the tension when account balances fall, and headlines grow louder. The goal of a well-designed financial plan is not to predict or avoid these periods. It is to function well in spite of them.
Some of the most valuable planning moves during downturns have nothing to do with trading and everything to do with taxes, timing, and flexibility.
Periods of market stress often create planning opportunities that are harder or less effective during strong markets. The actions below are not reactive trades. They are intentional planning decisions that can improve tax efficiency, flexibility, and long-term alignment when markets are under pressure.
Disclaimer: This is for educational purposes only and should not be considered advice. This is not a market prediction. This is an educational post relating to market circumstances. Every person’s situation is different and requires diligence when planning for retirement. Please consult with a financial advisor or a tax professional before making changes to your investments.
Key Takeaways
- Market downturns can** create planning opportunities**, not just discomfort
- Tax and estate strategies often become** more effective** when values are lower
- Hedges should be evaluated based on how they actually performed during stress
- Emotional and lifestyle impacts deserve as much attention as portfolio results
- A strong plan supports good decisions in difficult markets
Roth Conversions When Account Values Are Lower
Lower market values can reduce the tax cost of converting pre-tax retirement assets to Roth accounts. Converting a smaller balance means paying tax on a lower dollar amount for the same number of shares.
In practical terms, this means we can often do more with less.
If Roth conversions are already part of the plan, a downturn can accelerate the strategy. Lower valuations may allow more shares to be converted while staying within a targeted tax bracket. In some cases, this can pull forward conversions that were originally planned over several years, improving long-term tax efficiency without increasing current tax exposure.
These decisions should always be coordinated with broader tax planning. The goal is not to convert everything. It is to convert intentionally and with clear bracket awareness.
Tax-Loss Harvesting to Create Future Flexibility
When markets decline, some investments may temporarily fall below their purchase price. Realizing those losses can create a tax asset that may be used in future years.
Harvested losses can offset current or future capital gains. If losses exceed gains, a portion may offset ordinary income, with the remainder carried forward. This does not eliminate market risk, but it can improve after-tax outcomes over time.
The focus is not on market timing. It is on using volatility as an opportunity to strengthen the tax efficiency of the plan while maintaining the intended investment exposure.
Transferring out of your Estate
For households with estate planning goals, downturns can make gifting strategies more effective. When asset values are lower, more shares can be transferred using the same lifetime exemption.
This may apply to direct gifts, trust funding, or other estate planning strategies depending on the situation. Any future recovery then occurs outside of the taxable estate, shifting long-term growth to the next generation rather than compounding under future estate tax exposure.
These are long-term decisions, not market calls. Lower valuations can improve the efficiency of transfers that were already part of the plan.
Is your Hedging Strategy Working?
Market stress is the clearest test of any hedge or defensive strategy. This is the time to evaluate whether it actually did its job.
Questions worth revisiting include:
How correlated was the hedge during the downturn?
Did it meaningfully reduce volatility or drawdowns?
Did it behave as expected when markets were under pressure?
Not every hedge is meant to eliminate losses. Some are designed to reduce severity, smooth outcomes, or provide liquidity. A downturn provides real-world data to assess whether the trade-offs still make sense.
How Are You Holding Up?
Market downturns do not just test portfolios. They test people. Two important questions to ask during periods like this are:
How much of an impact did this downturn have on you emotionally?
Did it have any real impact on your retirement lifestyle?
Those answers can be very different.
A downturn may create anxiety even when the financial plan remains intact. In other cases, the impact may be tangible. Fewer trips. Less dining out. More hesitation around discretionary spending.
When market stress begins to affect lifestyle decisions, it is worth slowing down and reassessing. Not to react, but to confirm whether the plan is still doing what it was designed to do.
At the end of the day, a retirement plan exists to support your retirement lifestyle. Market declines will happen. The goal is to build a plan that allows you to move forward successfully in spite of them.
Final Thoughts
Market downturns are inevitable. What matters is not avoiding them, but having a plan that accounts for them.
When designed well, a financial plan provides structure during uncertainty and clarity during stress. It helps turn volatility into informed decisions rather than emotional reactions. The objective is not perfection. It is confidence in moving forward, even when markets are uncomfortable.